Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael Magoon's avatar

While it may just seem like common sense to most people, but the phrase ALL PEOPLE ARE CREATED EQUAL is loaded with ideological meaning.

What do you mean by that?

You then immediately go on to say that “each person should be judged solely based on merit.” But if everyone is inherently equal, then how can there be differences in merit between people?

Merit and Equality conflict with each other.

The reason why I ask is that the quest to create Equality is the most common reason for justifying a massive increase in the power of the government (which you say is bad) and many authoritarian governments (which you also say is bad). That is why this one statement potentially nullifies all the other statements in this manifesto.

John Stuart Mill, one of the most important Liberal philosophers, himself pointed out the strong tension between Liberty (the main Liberal goal) and Equality (the main goal of the Left), so I am not the only one to have noticed this problem.

Expand full comment
Suzannah Alexander's avatar

Hey Josh! I'm so glad to see you here, and I like what you are doing with this post. I think the big challege is that this is not being taught in schools anymore, and the univeristies are actively denigrating these ideals. I'm working on some reforms to change that here in Tennessee. Let me know when you and the crew get back this way. I'd love to fill you in and share insights.

Expand full comment
48 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?